Five Things to Consider When Selecting an M&A Advisor

Originally published August 15, 2017 · Updated November 2026
By Zane Tarence
When you choose an M&A advisor, look at five things:
- Trust: you can rely on them to tell you the truth, including when now isn’t the right time to sell.
- Experience: they’ve closed deals like yours, in your industry and at your size.
- Process: they follow a disciplined, documented process and don’t skip steps.
- Team: you know who will work on your deal, and they have time for it.
- Fee: most of their fee depends on a successful transaction, so they gain when you do.
Deciding to sell your company, or to sell part of it, is likely to be a once-in-a-lifetime decision. Anyone considering a transaction should be talking to, and ultimately engaging, an M&A advisor. Here’s what each of the five things means in practice, and how we approach them at Founders Advisors. If you want the specific questions to ask each firm before you sign, read our companion piece, Choosing an M&A Advisor.
1. Trust
Trust is the foundation of every relationship, and the relationship with your advisor is no different. You want someone guiding you who understands what you’re trying to achieve beyond the price: what happens to your employees, your customers and your role after the deal, and the legacy you’ve built.
A trustworthy advisor will also tell you when the timing isn’t right. Sometimes the best advice is to spend a year or two strengthening the business before going to market. Be wary of any advisor who is ready to launch a process before they understand your goals.
2. Experience
The M&A advisor you work with is there to create value through a competitive process, and it’s best if they have expertise in your industry. An industry expert better understands the key drivers of your business, the market dynamics and the likely buyers. Ask how many deals they’ve closed, how many were in your industry, and how many involved businesses of a similar size. You can check what they tell you against their published deals; ours are on our transactions page.
3. Process
Understanding the process, and how it’s run, is just as important. Selling a company takes discipline, and you don’t want your advisor cutting corners. Great advisors don’t skip steps. They represent your company well and work hard all the way through to closing, not just to a signed letter of intent.
Our sell-side process has five phases:
- Preparation and packaging
- Buyer research and development
- Marketing and buyer communications
- Negotiations and letter of intent
- Due diligence and closing
We first set out these phases in Understanding The M&A Process, and they still frame how we run a sale today. Ask any advisor you’re considering to walk you through their process in the same way.
4. Team
You’ll want to know what the team looks like: their experience and their backgrounds. Make sure you know who will be working on your deal, and get a commitment to that effect. The person who pitches isn’t always the person who runs the deal. Running a process properly takes a focused team of professionals, so you need to know your deal will get the time and attention it deserves. You can meet our people before you ever speak to us.
5. Fee
Price is always a consideration, but look at it in the context of the service you’re getting and the value the process creates. You want an advisor whose pay is aligned with the result you want. Reputable M&A advisors earn the vast majority of their fee after you’ve completed an acceptable transaction. Our guide to M&A advisor fees explains the common structures.
Why the relationship matters as much as the transaction
Many M&A advisors take a transactional approach to their engagements. While a sale is a transaction, we believe it’s extremely important for an M&A advisor to take a relational approach. That means getting to know your company, understanding your goals, and listening to what you want personally from the outcome. Not all advisors work this way, so be diligent when you interview them.
At Founders Advisors, every engagement follows the Founders Advisor Framework. It starts with Fit, a short intro call where you can ask us anything on this list and we’ll tell you honestly whether we’re the right fit. In Focus, we build a deeper understanding of your business and goals. In Frame, we present a range of options to help you set a course. Forge is where we make the engagement official, and Forward is where we start building your business transition. Read more about our sell-side advisory work.
Not sure if you’re ready? Start with the Investment Grade Assessment
If you’re not sure whether now is the time to sell, our Investment Grade Assessment is a good first step. It asks over 90 targeted questions across 12 sections, takes about 25 minutes, and helps you evaluate your company’s investability, marketability, and growth strategy, with a customized report you can act on.
Questions about selecting an M&A advisor
What is the most important thing to look for in an M&A advisor?
Trust comes first, because you’re relying on your advisor’s judgment for what is likely to be a once-in-a-lifetime decision. After that, look for experience with deals like yours, a disciplined process, a committed team, and a fee that rewards a successful outcome.
Will a good M&A advisor tell me if it isn’t the right time to sell?
Yes. A good advisor puts your goals ahead of getting a deal signed, and will tell you if the business could be worth more after a year or two of preparation. Ask every advisor you interview how they’d handle that conversation.
Do I need an M&A advisor with experience in my industry?
It helps. An advisor who knows your industry understands what drives value in your business and which buyers are most likely to pay for it. If you run a managed service provider, for example, read What Should I Look for When Choosing an M&A Advisor for My MSP? and Questions Every MSP Owner Should Ask Their M&A Advisor.
About the author
Zane Tarence is a Partner and Head of Business Development & Strategic Partnerships at Founders Advisors. Over the past 22 years, he has led and completed more than 97 private company transactions. Before joining Founders, Zane founded two technology businesses that he grew and sold to publicly traded companies, and he began his career at IBM. He is the author of “17 Reasons Your Company Is Not Investment Grade & What To Do About It” and holds Series 79, 63 and 24 securities licenses.
About Founders Advisors
At Founders Advisors, we advise founder-owned and family-owned middle-market companies on mergers and acquisitions. Duane Donner started the firm in 2003, and Founders Investment Banking became Founders Advisors in 2017. Today more than fifty professionals help owners sell their businesses, make acquisitions, and raise capital, with deep sector expertise in Business Services, Consumer, Healthcare, Industrials, and Technology. We work through the Founders Advisor Framework, and every relationship starts with listening. We’re not deal-chasers. We’re legacy stewards. Learn more about Founders Advisors.
In order to provide securities-related services discussed herein, certain principals of Founders Advisors, LLC are licensed with M&A Securities Group, Inc. or Founders M&A Advisory, LLC, both members FINRA and SIPC. M&A Securities Group and Founders are unaffiliated entities. Founders M&A Advisory, LLC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Founders Advisors, LLC. Neither Founders M&A Advisory, LLC nor Founders Advisors, LLC provide investment advice.